OCTOBER 2026 REPORT (7-9PM)
DCCS Panel members along with Chief Inspector Tom Cunningham, Karen Janicka (BWV Subject Matter Expert for Devon & Cornwall) and welcomed new panel members.
This month’s cases were filtered for both Stop and Search and Use of Force.
Before observing body-worn footage selected by the panel from the previous month's cases, the Chair reminded panel members of wellness practice and the opportunity for debriefing at the end of the meeting.
The following report identifies points to action, D&C Police responses, case assessments and outstanding areas that require investigation.
Body-Worn Video Assessment .
Body-Worn Video Assessment .
ASSESSING D&C POLICE STOP AND SEARCH [S&S]
OCTOBER 2026 REPORT (7-9PM)
Body-Worn Videos
Via Microsoft Teams, at the start of each case BWV Systems Administrator Karen Janicka, played the clip selected by the panel before members completed their anonymous assessment, discussed and submitted the below feedback.
Chief Inspector Tom Cunningham circulated this report with actions and recommendations to D&C Police Basic Command Unit, Operations Department, Learning and Development, Force Stop and Search Lead and Force Use of Force Lead.
All confirmed discussions, decisions and/or actions taken by officers and supervisors following receipt of the DCCS Panel report are identified in bold blue text.
Panel members use GOWISELY as part of their scrutiny assessment. It is an acronym that officers must use to provide information to a subject before the Stop and Search. If the GOWISELY procedure is not followed then the S&S is highly likely to have been unlawful.
GROUNDS of the search
OBJECT of the search
WARRANT card [if not in uniform]
IDENTITY [officer name & number]
STATION [where officer is based]
ENTITLEMENT to receipt
LEGAL power used
YOU are detained for S&S
S&S Case 1 - An officer from the neighbourhood policing team stopped and searched a female under Section 23 of the Misuse of Drugs Act.
The grounds were that the subject was openly smoking a crack pipe in a public place in a known problem area. The officer searched the subject’s bag and found cannabis residue on a pipe. The subject was not arrested.
Actions to be commended:
Clear and proportionate grounds. The panel noted that the grounds for this stop were straightforward and well-founded, the subject was openly using a crack pipe in front of the officer in a public place. Members felt there was no ambiguity about the basis for the search and acknowledged that the officer acted appropriately in responding to what was visible behaviour in a known problem area.
Appropriate limitation of search to the bag. The panel highlighted that the officer searched the bag rather than the person, which Miranda confirmed was correct, as a male officer, searching a female subject would not have been appropriate, and members noted this reflected sound judgement within the constraints of the situation.
Investigation, responses and learning required with:
Communication in terms of tone and engagement throughout the search. The panel’s concern was the quality of communication during the encounter. Members highlighted that the interaction felt cold and at times patronising with a tone that suggested familiarity bred by repetition rather than genuine engagement with the individual in front of them. Members felt this person still deserved to be treated with dignity and respect, regardless of how frequently similar encounters occur. It was noted that even a small amount of human communication during the search acknowledging the person, speaking through what is happening, matters because it may be the only moment of respect that person receives that day.
BWV camera positioning - officer safety and evidential value. The panel highlighted that for much of the encounter, the camera was pointed downward and captured little of the interaction, members could not see what was happening or hear the officer clearly. It was confirmed that this was a concern not just for scrutiny purposes but for the officer’s own protection: had anything been found or a complaint made, the footage would not have supported the officer. The panel noted this as a thematic issue worth tracking, if camera positioning consistently fails to capture encounters, it raises questions about whether the kit is working as intended or whether officers need further guidance.
GOWISELY - speed of delivery. It was also acknowledged that while the statutory elements appeared to have been covered, they were delivered quickly, particularly to a subject who was visibly under the influence and unlikely to have absorbed everything said. The panel felt this pointed to a pattern of GOWISELY becoming a recited formula rather than a communication tool, and highlighted that slowing the process down serves both the subject and the officer.
Purpose and proportionality - what was the outcome? The panel raised the question directly: what was the point of this interaction? The subject was not dealing, not causing harm to others, and was not arrested. Several members echoed the concern that if officers are repeatedly searching the same individuals in the same locations without any broader intervention strategy, the value of each individual stop needs to be considered.
Response received from visiting BCU Commander
“It’s almost really helpful to hear your perception of what you’ve just seen. You’re absolutely right, we didn’t search the person, and I would have expected a female officer to come if he was searching the person. What I did hear was he told her why, because she was smoking the crack pipe in front of him, so I’m comfortable with that. I think he said the GOWISELY, but it was really quick, and you’re talking to somebody who clearly is under the influence, whether she understood, or whether this is daily business, it feels like this is probably daily business, and we’ve gone into that part rather than what I would expect the core training to be. The power gives him the ability to search the bag. We didn’t see him search the person, and I’m comfortable with that. Was it the best I’ve seen? Probably not. Was I comfortable with it? Probably just comfortable with it. It would be really helpful to play it with him as part of this process afterwards, just to understand his thought process. The complacency, the perception of complacency, probably came out in that video. But I think he had the grounds for it, and I’m comfortable he had the grounds to search.”
S&S BWV 1 ASSESSMENT
D&C POLICE RESPONSE TO S&S BWV 1
Officer’s response not received
Panel response:
S&S Case 2 - Officers conducting a vehicle stop check found a driver with a provisional licence who was not displaying L-plates and had failed a roadside drug swipe test, testing positive for cannabis.
During conversation, the subject’s friend, also present in the vehicle and voluntarily disclosed he had cannabis in his bag. The officer then conducted a Section 23 search of the friend. The case involves a student officer and tutor constable. An interpreter was present via a friend.
Actions to be commended:
Calm handling of a complex multi-person stop. The panel acknowledged that officers were managing several individuals simultaneously, a driver under arrest, passengers, and an interpreter, and that the general tone of the interaction was calm and non-confrontational. Members noted the subject was cooperative and that the outcome was proportionate.
Honest and transparent explanation of powers. The panel noted the officer was open about the basis for the search and took time to explain the drug driving process, including what would happen at the station and what the blood test would determine. Members felt this refl ected a genuine attempt to communicate despite the language barrier.
Investigation, responses and learning required with:
Tone and perceived informality. Panel members highlighted that the officers’ manner felt overly casual for what was a serious situation. It was also noted that the conversation at times sounded like practice rather than a real encounter, and members felt the informal tone, while perhaps intended to put the subject at ease, risked undermining the gravity of the arrest and the search.
GOWISELY. The panel highlighted that while some elements were covered, GOWISELY was not followed in full, particularly given this involved a student officer. Members felt this was a missed opportunity for the tutor to model good practice, if the tutor does not consistently deliver all elements, the student officer will not either.
Female officer searching male subject. It was raised that a female officer was conducting the search of a male subject. The police confi rmed a street search of this nature can be conducted by a female officer, and that it would form part of the student officer’s sign-off requirements, but acknowledged the panel’s question was fair and worth confi rming as intentional practice.
Language and interpretation. Panel members noted that while an interpreter was established, the officers did not consistently engage through them. The panel felt that if an interpreter is present, all key communication, particularly the caution and grounds, should be directed through that person rather than switching between the subject and bystanders. It was also highlighted that without this, it was unclear how much the subject understood.
Student officer - tutor responsibility. The panel felt the tutor missed several opportunities to step in and correct or guide the student officer. It was highlighted that the tutor himself appeared uncertain about which power to use at one point, which would have been visible and potentially unsettling to anyone watching. Members felt the tutor’s role is not just to observe but to ensure the encounter models the standard expected.
Response received from visiting BCU Commander
“Clearly it is a student officer with the tutor. I quite liked his style, to be fair, it actually showed his humour by checking his legislation, because if that person wasn’t in a car, it would have been a summary only offence, which meant they would then have to have a different power to search, and he seemed to check that with himself as he was teaching. So I quite liked the fact that that was the human side. However, I do take on board that I don’t think the full GOWISELY was there, even more so with a student officer, I would have expected it to follow GOWISELY, because that is a nice way of teaching and actually sets them up for the rest of their career. And the communication was quite interesting, wasn’t it? Because they did clarify that he understood, but then also used the friend as well, so that made it a bit clunky. Probably it would have been simpler to ask the other two to move away and then speak to that one person, because they said they could understand and were communicating quite well. The search in the street can be conducted by a female officer, even if a male officer is present, I’m comfortable with what I would expect. But I would see that was probably part of their sign-off, the whole search process right through to searching for the items. I think there’s defi nitely some learning and a good conversation to have with them, and I actually quite look forward to sharing that with them.”
S&S BWV 2 ASSESSMENT
D&C POLICE RESPONSE TO S&S BWV 2
Officer’s response not received
Panel response:
S&S Case 3 - Officers were called to a hotel following reports of a male acting suspiciously and attempting to get into a vehicle, with staff suggesting he may have a knife.
The subject appeared to be under the infl uence of substances. During the encounter officers spoke with hotel staff to establish what had happened. No knife was found. The subject was subsequently arrested on suspicion of a public order offence, causing a nuisance and taken away by officers.
Actions to be commended:
Female officer - respectful and subject-focused approach. The panel highlighted that the female officer maintained a consistently respectful tone throughout the encounter, engaging directly with the subject and treating him as an individual. Members noted her communication was calm and centred on the person rather than the process, and felt this was a positive example of procedural justice in practice.
Gathering context from witnesses. The panel noted that officers took time to speak with hotel staff and piece together what had actually happened, rather than proceeding solely on the initial report. Members felt this refl ected good professional practice establishing facts before drawing conclusions and acknowledged that the officers’ conclusion that no serious criminal offence had occurred showed sound judgement.
Investigation, responses and learning required with:
"Male officer communication style and dehumanising language. The panel’s most concern was the conduct of the male officer. Members highlighted comments that members felt were inappropriate and dehumanising, discussing the subject’s previous arrests in front of others, referring to taking him away in a way that suggested he was an object rather than a person, and making remarks that were not necessary to the encounter. It was also noted that all three of the" evening’s cases had highlighted communication as a common theme, and that this case brought that into sharpest focus.
Communication. Members noted that having several officers present and all engaging at once created confusion and made it harder for the subject, who was under the infl uence, to follow what was happening. The panel felt there was a clear leadership question about who was responsible for managing the encounter and ensuring it was handled consistently.
GOWISELY and talking through the search. Panel Members highlighted that going through GOWISELY is not just a legal requirement, it serves a purpose for the officer too, giving a structure that slows the moment down, creates a professional pace, and ensures communication happens throughout. Members noted that in this case, as in others, the search was conducted without that consistent verbal thread, and felt it was a pattern worth feeding back.
Subject’s wellbeing and vulnerability. The panel noted the subject appeared to be under the infl uence and potentially vulnerable. Members felt there was a question about what support, if any, was offered or considered, and whether the outcome of a public order arrest appropriately addressed the underlying situation.
Response received from visiting BCU Commander
“I think it's a really fair comment, and for me, the grounds were there, I’m really comfortable with how they did the search. Just the communication absolutely could have been better. And I think you summarised it really nicely, just use GOWISELY, and that would have slowed it down and been quite simple. Because I actually think they did say it all, but it was in a couple of chunks. I think there was probably more engagement with the female officer than with the male officer, I think he responded to her better, but if that’s the case, then perhaps she should take over rather than the male officer keep coming back in. I’m really comfortable with the feedback on that.”
S&S BWV 3 ASSESSMENT
D&C POLICE RESPONSE TO S&S BWV 3
Officer’s response not received
Panel response:
ASSESSING D&C POLICE USE OF FORCE [UOF]
OCTOBER 2026 REPORT (7-9PM)
Body-Worn Videos
Panel members use PLANTER as part of their Use of Force scrutiny assessment:
PROPORTIONATE amount of force implemented
LENGTH of force used
ACTIONS of subject warranted use of force
NECESSARY to use force to protect the subject, officers or members of the public
TYPE used was minimum appropriate
ETHICAL to use force in the situation
REASONABLE for officer(s) to employ
UOF CASE 1 - Officers attended a public park / football club grounds following a call from parents that their 13-year-old son was refusing to go home with them..
The young person was already known to police in connection with a report of criminal damage to a nursing home window. Officers spent considerable time negotiating with the young person, who was surrounded by a large group of peers, before ultimately arresting him for criminal damage when he refused to leave with his parents and indicated he would run away. Force was used to handcuff and remove him. He was transported to his home address where officers spent time with the family. A PPN was confi rmed as mandatory in cases involving use of force on a child.
Actions to be commended:
Extended negotiation before force. The panel highlighted that officers spent a significant amount of time, far longer than might be typical, attempting to negotiate with the young person before arresting him. Members noted that the threshold for getting hands on a child was treated seriously.
Keeping the young person on his feet. It was specifi cally highlighted that officers managed to keep the young person upright throughout the use of force, rather than taking him to the floor. She noted this was significant given the large audience watching, taking a child to the floor in that environment could have escalated the situation rapidly.
Rapport building and de-escalation in the car. The panel noted that once removed from the peer group, the young person’s behaviour changed significantly, he became calmer, more communicative, and officers were able to remove the handcuffs. Members felt this demonstrated that the decision to remove him from the environment was the right one, and highlighted the rapport-building that followed as a positive example of how officers can shift the dynamic once the immediate pressure is removed.
Officers going into the home. It was noted that the female officer accompanied the young person to his room and ensured the right support was in place in the house. Members felt this went beyond what was required and refl ected a genuine concern for the young person’s welfare.
Investigation, responses and learning required with:Language. Panel members highlighted that some of the male officer’s comments were unhelpful and likely made the situation worse, telling the young person he was embarrassing himself, that he was showing off, and making remarks about his previous arrest history in front of his peers. Members felt these comments were likely to entrench the young person’s position rather than give him a way out, and that they were unnecessary.
The peer audience - dispersal as a tactic. Panel members highlighted that the significant number of young people and adults watching the encounter was a major factor in how it unfolded. Members also noted the young person was clearly performing for his audience and that his behaviour shifted markedly once he was away from them. The panel felt dispersing the crowd earlier could have changed the dynamic of the entire encounter, and raised whether officers considered or attempted this.
Offering the young person a way out addressing his concerns. The negotiation went round in circles partly because officers kept returning to the same argument, his parents had responsibility, he had to go home without acknowledging or addressing what the young person was actually saying. He disclosed that he was worried about his mother’s drinking and what would happen when he got home. Members felt officers could have offered more acknowledging his concerns, suggesting what support could be put in place, giving him something to hold onto beyond just the instruction to comply.
Asking a 13-year-old girl to explain the situation to him. One officer asked the young person’s girlfriend, also a child, to explain to him why he needed to go home. Members felt this placed an inappropriate burden on a child and potentially put her in a diffi cult position.
PPN - mandatory completion and IT gap. A PPN is mandatory when force is used on a child and that this should have been submitted. It was noted that at present the system cannot easily link a PPN to a use of force report, meaning compliance has to be checked manually, she confi rmed this is being pursued as an IT fix.
Response received from visiting BCU Commander
I was really pleased to see that they held their nerve around keeping him on his feet. I think if they’d taken him to the floor, that could have escalated really, really quickly with the people around him because it looks really aggressive, even though, arguably, we do that for safety a lot of the time. You could see that the officers were out of breath, so it took all their effort to get him in the car. And one of the key bits for me, it absolutely shows the rapport building just takes time, but it’s significant, isn’t it, how they then communicated in the car? They moved the handcuffs, handcuffs aren’t comfortable. So from the use of force, I’m really okay with what they did. They were quite admirable because that did take some time. The female officer went with him to his room and made sure they’ve got the right support in the house, and we would have had to have submitted what we call a PPN, that’s one of the key bits I’m looking at for use of force. If you use force on a child, it’s mandatory to put that form in so we can see how many times we’re using force on children, and if we get repeated children, what intervention we can put in place. So that wider partnership would be supported. Clearly we don’t know whether mum was alcoholic or not, his perception is she is, and that was definitely one of his anxieties about going home. And interestingly, dad was quite quiet, wasn’t he? Whether he did that intentionally or whether he thought he might unsettle the situation even more, I don’t know. But I was really pleased to see how they were engaging with him in the car, because it feels like by the time they get home, they would be able to have a much more mature conversation with him around his feelings and his needs.”
D&C POLICE RESPONSE TO UOF BWV 1
Officer’s response not received
Panel response:
UOF CASE 2 - Two officers travelling at speed on a dual carriageway with emergency lights and sirens activated were unable to pass a vehicle in the fast lane that failed to move over despite the emergency signals.
The vehicle was eventually stopped. The driver was found to have no insurance and no driving licence and had been on his phone at the time. The officer placed the driver under arrest. Compliant handcuffi ng was applied. The footage was limited due to darkness.
Actions to be commended:
Officers acting decisively to protect public safety. Panel members highlighted that the officers’ decision to stop this vehicle was not a minor matter, a driver with no licence, no insurance, using a phone, blocking an emergency vehicle on a dual carriageway at night represented a genuine danger to other road users and to the officers themselves. Members felt strongly that this kind of enforcement should be recognised and that the officers who do it deserve appreciation.
Calm and professional arrest in diffi cult conditions. Given the environment was dark, roadside, on a dual carriageway, members noted the arrest was handled calmly and the caution was delivered. The panel acknowledged the limitations of what they could assess given the visibility, but were broadly comfortable with what they saw.
Investigation, responses and learning required with:Limited footage - darkness and visibility. The panel noted that the nature of this footage made it very diffi cult to fully scrutinise the encounter. Members acknowledged this is an inherent challenge with roadside incidents at night but noted it as a factor in what the panel could meaningfully assess.
Forms - incomplete fields given the circumstances. Members noted that the forms could not be completed fully for this case given the limited visibility of the footage. The panel acknowledged this and noted it as a practical limitation rather than a concern about officer conduct.
Response received from visiting BCU Commander
“The commander did not provide a direct verbal response to this case in the session. The panel’s consensus was that officers had acted appropriately and the case was broadly positive.”
D&C POLICE RESPONSE TO UOF BWV 2
Officer’s response not received
Panel response:
Legal Requirements
Officers are mandated to switch on their body-worn video (BWV) cameras from the beginning of any incident. During a Stop and Search, officers must provide specific information to the person being searched. While there is no strictly prescribed order, the College of Policing recommends using the mnemonic GOWISELY to ensure all statutory elements are covered.
For Use of Force, the College of Policing toolkit outlines PLANTER as a structured approach to ensure actions are justified and proportionate.
What is Procedural Justice?
Panel members score each BWV case using a consistent academic framework to inform how well the officers did in meeting legal requirements but also in the way they treated the person being stopped. Procedural Justice involves the pillars outlined below:
Voice: Was the subject allowed to give their side of the story or ask questions (within reason)?
Neutrality: Were the officer’s decisions unbiased and guided by transparent reasoning?
Dignity and Respect: Was the subject treated with courtesy and respect throughout the encounter?
Trustworthy Motives: Did the officer seek to explain and encourage understanding?
Accessible communication: Was the language used clear and easily understood by the subject?
Appropriate Tone: Was the tone of voice calm, respectful, and suitable for the situation?
Interested in making a difference?
Improve accountability, transparency and trust between D&C Police and the communities they serve.
Receive free training, work alongside inspiring individuals and help make positive changes.
Scrutinise Stop & Search and Use of Force, or join sub-committees to share your skills or learn new ones.